When Is A Guarantee Not A Guarantee?
By Shawn Surmick - November 13, 2026
I am going to start this article off with a controversial statement: Third-party grading is a necessary evil in the antiques and collectibles trade. The very first collectibles that ever benefited as a result of third-party grading were coins. This is one of the many reasons why coins became such an important category within the trade. Today, third-party grading has spread to a plethora of different collecting categories, for better or worse. Certain collectibles are better poised to benefit from third-party grading than others. Case in point, coins, paper money, stamps, trading cards, and comic books were a natural progression to the benefits of assessing an item's condition and sealing it in a tamper evident plastic holder. Other collectibles like vintage toys, action figures, video games, and even vintage factory sealed electronics are now also being third-party graded, and it is not without some controversy.
Venturing back to the mid-1980s in my DeLorean time machine, when coins were first being third-party graded, two companies emerged as dominant players. One was the Numismatic Guaranty Company (also known as NGC) and the other was Professional Coin Grading Service (also known as PCGS). These two companies would go on to shape the coin collecting market for the next several decades. Both companies benefited from standing behind the items they graded. If an item put in one of their tamper evident holders was later deemed not as stated or downright counterfeit, both companies would make the purchaser of the said coin whole. This usually either meant reexamining the coin in question or, in certain instances, writing out a big check and admitting that they had made a mistake. As a result of these actions, support for both of these companies grew, and today both NGC and PCGS are still two of the most prominent third-party graders (of coins) in the trade. The journey to get this point, however, was not always easy.
Over the years, both companies faced questions about their grading standards, and some collectors and dealers did not always agree with the grades that were being assigned by both of these companies. However, both companies stood behind the coins they graded. Then finally in the early 2000s, NGC updated their terms and conditions to limit certain copper and nickel coins that they had encapsulated. The new terms would limit copper and nickel coins to a 10-year grading term. As a coin collector, this did make sense at the time. As someone who lives in the Philadelphia area where our summers can feel like stepping into a sauna, both copper and nickel coins are environmentally sensitive. Meaning if these types of coins are not stored properly, they can easily discolor and tone even in the third-party grading holder. A lot of novice collectors incorrectly assume that third-party grading enclosures are airtight. This is a long dispelled internet rumor, as the tamper evident holders that any third-party grading company uses cannot be fully airtight. Otherwise, you would risk damaging the collectible inside because it would need to be firmly placed against the plastic holder. This is true for all third-party graded collectibles, and if you don’t believe me, simply take any low value third-party graded collectible of your choice and submerge it in water and leave it there overnight. I assure you that the item will be soaking wet by morning, if not sooner. At this time, NGC’s updated terms stated that most other types of coins were excluded from this policy change. Therefore, any coin composed of silver, gold, or even platinum was exempt.
Ironically, it was around this time that collectors, investors, and dealers operating in the coin market, were more concerned with apparent grading inconsistencies at the hands of NGC and PCGS. Legendary numismatist John Albanese was aware of this, and his solution was groundbreaking at the time. Launched in 2007, he created the company known as Certified Acceptance Corporation (also known as CAC) to combat this growing problem. The CAC at first was not a full fledged third-party grading company. What CAC did was evaluate coins already graded by either NGC or PCGS, and if they at least agreed with the grade, they assigned a tamper evident CAC sticker to the tamper evident holder. Coins that were rejected by CAC after review were simply not stickered. Over the years, coins with CAC certification started to sell for significant premiums at auction and through dealers. The CAC was so successful that a lot of high-profile collectors and investors will only buy an NGC- or PCGS-graded coin if it also has CAC approval. John Albanese is credited with completely upending the rare coin marketplace, and in 2023 his company decided to open a full fledged third-party grading division to compete head on with both PCGS and NGC.
During the pandemic, graded coins was one of the markets that became red hot, and with precious metal prices still at all-time high price points (even with market corrections occurring over the past few months) interest from collectors and investors is increasing. By this time both NGC and PCGS have now certified millions upon millions of coins. But in June of 2026, NGC would do something seen as controversial by some, and downright stupid by others (I am in this camp). Remember those terms that NGC updated in the early 2000s to limit their guarantee for copper and nickel coins? Well, the company quietly went and updated it to include all coins, including silver, gold, and platinum coins. This caused most high-profile collectors and investors to take notice and push back against this policy. After all, should the grade and/or guarantee of a third-party graded collectible expire? If so, what would the point be of purchasing a graded collectible right before the expiration of the guarantee? Graded collectibles have a distinct certification number right on the holder that can be looked up on any third-party grading company’s website. This also tells you when the said item was graded. So, if a coin was graded nine years ago and has only a ten-year guarantee, why would anyone pay a premium for that coin when after buying they have to pay to send it back to the grading company to verify the grade? If the coin requires regrading, it could come back at a lower grade, costing the buyer thousands of lost dollars in the possess. Thankfully, the internet (along with collectors like myself) pushed back. And as of this writing, NGC appears to have reversed course on this decision. I was perplexed when I first heard the news. The NGC is a leading third-party grading company, but many would argue that they currently rank behind PCGS, and with CAC quickly building credibility and value in this space, the question becomes who at NGC came up with this terrible idea? Given the fact that PCGS and CAC would not be following in NGC’s footsteps, had NGC continued in this direction, they would certainly lose the trust of the coin collecting community.
I have long argued that auction companies and grading companies have too much power in these markets. With decisions like this being made, more regulation is needed in these markets, especially in a day and age where private equity, Wall Street, and emotionless corporate conglomerates are entering this space en masse, convincing collectors that these markets are ripe for investing. Why would anyone invest in a graded collectible if the grading company can simply limit how long a grade (or authentication for that matter) is good for? Thank you NGC for reversing this disastrous decision.
Shawn Surmick has been an avid collector since the age of 12. He currently resides in his hometown of Boyertown, Pa., and is a passionate collector of antiques and collectibles. His articles focus on various topics affecting the marketplace.
Venturing back to the mid-1980s in my DeLorean time machine, when coins were first being third-party graded, two companies emerged as dominant players. One was the Numismatic Guaranty Company (also known as NGC) and the other was Professional Coin Grading Service (also known as PCGS). These two companies would go on to shape the coin collecting market for the next several decades. Both companies benefited from standing behind the items they graded. If an item put in one of their tamper evident holders was later deemed not as stated or downright counterfeit, both companies would make the purchaser of the said coin whole. This usually either meant reexamining the coin in question or, in certain instances, writing out a big check and admitting that they had made a mistake. As a result of these actions, support for both of these companies grew, and today both NGC and PCGS are still two of the most prominent third-party graders (of coins) in the trade. The journey to get this point, however, was not always easy.
Over the years, both companies faced questions about their grading standards, and some collectors and dealers did not always agree with the grades that were being assigned by both of these companies. However, both companies stood behind the coins they graded. Then finally in the early 2000s, NGC updated their terms and conditions to limit certain copper and nickel coins that they had encapsulated. The new terms would limit copper and nickel coins to a 10-year grading term. As a coin collector, this did make sense at the time. As someone who lives in the Philadelphia area where our summers can feel like stepping into a sauna, both copper and nickel coins are environmentally sensitive. Meaning if these types of coins are not stored properly, they can easily discolor and tone even in the third-party grading holder. A lot of novice collectors incorrectly assume that third-party grading enclosures are airtight. This is a long dispelled internet rumor, as the tamper evident holders that any third-party grading company uses cannot be fully airtight. Otherwise, you would risk damaging the collectible inside because it would need to be firmly placed against the plastic holder. This is true for all third-party graded collectibles, and if you don’t believe me, simply take any low value third-party graded collectible of your choice and submerge it in water and leave it there overnight. I assure you that the item will be soaking wet by morning, if not sooner. At this time, NGC’s updated terms stated that most other types of coins were excluded from this policy change. Therefore, any coin composed of silver, gold, or even platinum was exempt.
Ironically, it was around this time that collectors, investors, and dealers operating in the coin market, were more concerned with apparent grading inconsistencies at the hands of NGC and PCGS. Legendary numismatist John Albanese was aware of this, and his solution was groundbreaking at the time. Launched in 2007, he created the company known as Certified Acceptance Corporation (also known as CAC) to combat this growing problem. The CAC at first was not a full fledged third-party grading company. What CAC did was evaluate coins already graded by either NGC or PCGS, and if they at least agreed with the grade, they assigned a tamper evident CAC sticker to the tamper evident holder. Coins that were rejected by CAC after review were simply not stickered. Over the years, coins with CAC certification started to sell for significant premiums at auction and through dealers. The CAC was so successful that a lot of high-profile collectors and investors will only buy an NGC- or PCGS-graded coin if it also has CAC approval. John Albanese is credited with completely upending the rare coin marketplace, and in 2023 his company decided to open a full fledged third-party grading division to compete head on with both PCGS and NGC.
During the pandemic, graded coins was one of the markets that became red hot, and with precious metal prices still at all-time high price points (even with market corrections occurring over the past few months) interest from collectors and investors is increasing. By this time both NGC and PCGS have now certified millions upon millions of coins. But in June of 2026, NGC would do something seen as controversial by some, and downright stupid by others (I am in this camp). Remember those terms that NGC updated in the early 2000s to limit their guarantee for copper and nickel coins? Well, the company quietly went and updated it to include all coins, including silver, gold, and platinum coins. This caused most high-profile collectors and investors to take notice and push back against this policy. After all, should the grade and/or guarantee of a third-party graded collectible expire? If so, what would the point be of purchasing a graded collectible right before the expiration of the guarantee? Graded collectibles have a distinct certification number right on the holder that can be looked up on any third-party grading company’s website. This also tells you when the said item was graded. So, if a coin was graded nine years ago and has only a ten-year guarantee, why would anyone pay a premium for that coin when after buying they have to pay to send it back to the grading company to verify the grade? If the coin requires regrading, it could come back at a lower grade, costing the buyer thousands of lost dollars in the possess. Thankfully, the internet (along with collectors like myself) pushed back. And as of this writing, NGC appears to have reversed course on this decision. I was perplexed when I first heard the news. The NGC is a leading third-party grading company, but many would argue that they currently rank behind PCGS, and with CAC quickly building credibility and value in this space, the question becomes who at NGC came up with this terrible idea? Given the fact that PCGS and CAC would not be following in NGC’s footsteps, had NGC continued in this direction, they would certainly lose the trust of the coin collecting community.
I have long argued that auction companies and grading companies have too much power in these markets. With decisions like this being made, more regulation is needed in these markets, especially in a day and age where private equity, Wall Street, and emotionless corporate conglomerates are entering this space en masse, convincing collectors that these markets are ripe for investing. Why would anyone invest in a graded collectible if the grading company can simply limit how long a grade (or authentication for that matter) is good for? Thank you NGC for reversing this disastrous decision.
Shawn Surmick has been an avid collector since the age of 12. He currently resides in his hometown of Boyertown, Pa., and is a passionate collector of antiques and collectibles. His articles focus on various topics affecting the marketplace.

SHARE
PRINT